Got the Wrong Cut of Meat in Your Delivery? Here's What to Do

By Anna Smith•

First, take a breath. This happens more often than you'd think, and the good news is that most mix-ups are fixable—and sometimes even a happy accident. I've spent years around meat, from the sourcing floor to the kitchen, and the key is knowing how to evaluate what you did receive and whether it can still work for your meal plan. Let me walk you through exactly what to do, step by step.

Step One: Verify the Mistake Immediately

Before you panic, confirm that the cut is truly wrong. Meat can look different depending on how it's trimmed, packaged, or even how it was frozen. A sirloin steak, for example, can sometimes resemble a New York strip if both are boneless and similarly sized. Check the label on the package—every True Nature Meats product has a clear product name and cooking instructions. If the label says Ribeye Steak but the meat inside looks leaner and more triangular, you may have received a sirloin instead. Compare the marbling, shape, and fat cap. Ribeyes have generous, buttery marbling throughout; sirloins are leaner with a more uniform grain.

If you're still unsure, snap a photo and compare it to the product images on our website. Marbling patterns and fat distribution are reliable identifiers.

Step Two: Assess Whether the Wrong Cut Can Still Work

Here's where your meat knowledge pays off. Not all swaps are disasters. In fact, some substitutions can be delicious if you adjust your cooking method.

  • If you ordered a Ribeye but received a Sirloin: The sirloin is leaner and less forgiving of high, dry heat. Instead of grilling hot-and-fast, consider marinating it or cooking it to no more than medium-rare (130-135°F) to avoid toughness. Alternatively, slice it thin for stir-fry or steak tacos.
  • If you ordered a New York Strip but received a Ribeye: You've actually been upgraded. The ribeye's higher fat content makes it more forgiving and more flavorful. Cook it the same way—hot grill or cast iron—but expect juicier results.
  • If you ordered a brisket but received a steak cut: This is a bigger divergence. Brisket is a tough, collagen-rich cut meant for low-and-slow cooking. A steak cut like sirloin or strip will dry out and become tough if braised. Instead, cook it as a steak. If you ordered pulled pork and received a chicken product, the same logic applies—adjust your cooking time and method accordingly.
  • If you ordered chicken but received beef (or vice versa): Cooking times and safe internal temperatures differ. Chicken needs to reach 165°F; beef can be enjoyed at 130-145°F depending on doneness. Do not cook them the same way. Adjust your thermometer and your timing.

Step Three: Contact Customer Service Promptly

This is the most important action. Once you've identified the error, reach out to True Nature Meats customer service within 24-48 hours of delivery. Have your order number, the product name you ordered, and a photo of what you received ready. Reputable companies—and we take pride in this—will make it right. That typically means a replacement shipment or a credit. Do not throw the meat away until you've spoken with them; they may ask you to return it or simply tell you to keep it.

Step Four: Food Safety Considerations

If the wrong cut arrived and you're unsure of its origin or handling, follow standard food safety protocols. Frozen meat should arrive solid or mostly frozen. If it's thawed but still cold (below 40°F), it's safe to refreeze or cook immediately. If it's warm to the touch or has been above 40°F for more than two hours, do not eat it. When in doubt, throw it out. No meal is worth a foodborne illness.

Step Five: Learn From the Experience

Receiving the wrong cut is an opportunity to expand your cooking repertoire. If you've never cooked a Wagyu Sirloin but ordered a Classic Sirloin, now you know what that premium marbling feels like. If you ordered Texas Smoked Brisket and received Brazilian Garlic Steak, you've just discovered a new flavor profile. Keep a mental note—or better yet, a cooking journal—of what you received and how you adapted. Next time you're meal planning, you'll have more confidence.

The Bottom Line

A wrong cut is rarely a ruined meal. With a little knowledge, you can pivot, adapt, and still put something delicious on the table. And if you can't? We'll make it right. That's the promise of True Nature Meats: premium quality, honest service, and the belief that every meal—even the unexpected ones—can bring people together. So pull up a chair, adjust your cooking method, and enjoy the true nature of your meal.

Back to Journal