What to Do If Your Meat Delivery Isn't Right

By Anna Smith•

Let me be straight with you: when you order premium meat, you expect premium results. At True Nature Meats, we stand behind every cut that leaves our facility. But if something isn't right—whether it's a quality issue, a packaging problem, or your steak simply didn't meet expectations—here's exactly how we handle it.

The Short Version: Your Satisfaction is Guaranteed

If your meat arrives unsatisfactory for any reason, contact our customer service team within 24 hours of delivery. We'll make it right—typically with a replacement or refund. No complicated return shipping of perishable goods. No hoops to jump through.

Step-by-Step: What to Do

1. Inspect Your Delivery Immediately

The moment your box arrives, open it. Check the internal temperature (meat should arrive frozen or fully chilled). Look for:

  • Package damage or leaks
  • Freezer burn or ice crystals
  • Off-odors or discoloration
  • Temperature abuse (thawed meat that should be frozen)

2. Document the Issue

Take clear photos of the problem—the packaging, the meat itself, and the temperature indicator if included. This helps our team understand exactly what went wrong and speeds up resolution.

3. Contact Us Within 24 Hours

Reach out through our website or call customer service. Have your order number ready. Describe what happened and share your photos.

4. We Handle the Rest

You don't need to ship anything back. Perishable meat products can't be returned for food safety reasons—and we wouldn't ask you to. Once we verify the issue, we'll process your replacement or refund.

Common Scenarios and How We Handle Them

Damaged packaging during shipping: This happens rarely, but when it does, we replace the affected items immediately. The cold chain is critical for food safety, and compromised packaging means compromised quality.

Temperature issues: If your meat arrived thawed or warm, that's a shipping failure on our end. We'll replace the entire order or issue a full refund. Never consume meat that has been above 40°F for more than two hours.

Quality concerns: Maybe the marbling on your Ribeye Steak wasn't what you expected, or the texture of your Texas Smoked Brisket seemed off. We take quality seriously. Send us your feedback, and we'll make it right.

Wrong product received: If you ordered Brazilian Garlic Steak but received Classic Sirloin instead, we'll send the correct product and let you keep the mistake as our apology.

What We Don't Cover

A few things fall outside our guarantee:

  • Personal taste preferences (you decided you don't like teriyaki after ordering Japanese Teriyaki Steak)
  • Cooking errors (that Wagyu Sirloin Steak was perfect—you just cooked it to well-done)
  • Orders placed more than 30 days ago
  • Items not stored properly after delivery (meat left on the counter, not frozen)

The Science Behind Our Guarantee

Here's something most people don't consider: meat quality degrades through a process called proteolysis—enzyme activity that breaks down proteins over time. Temperature fluctuations accelerate this. That's why we use industry-leading cold storage and ship within 1-2 business days from our three U.S. locations.

Our pre-cooked, seasoned meats have an advantage here. They've already been cooked to safe internal temperatures using methods like smoking (which adds antimicrobial compounds from wood smoke) and proper heat processing. This means less risk of spoilage during transit compared to raw meat.

Food Safety First

If you ever receive meat that looks, smells, or feels questionable, do not taste it to check. Pathogenic bacteria like E. coli and Salmonella don't always change the appearance or smell of meat. When in doubt, throw it out—and contact us for a replacement.

How We Prevent Problems Before They Happen

Every True Nature Meats product undergoes rigorous testing at our sourcing locations—from Argentina's Pampas to the American West. Our USDA-certified facilities maintain the highest standards. We use old-school smoking methods (no liquid smoke, no injections) because those traditional techniques naturally preserve quality.

But no system is perfect. Shipping frozen meat across the country introduces variables. That's why we've built our guarantee into the price of every cut.

The Bottom Line

If your meat isn't perfect, we want to know. Contact us within 24 hours, show us what happened, and we'll fix it. No arguments, no fine print, no shipping your spoiled meat back to us.

At True Nature Meats, we're not just selling premium cuts—we're selling peace of mind. Every New York Strip, every Texas Smoked Brisket, every Japanese Teriyaki Chicken breast comes with a promise: real meat, made right, backed fully. Because mealtime should be about joy, not worry.

Pro tip: Before your next order, make sure your freezer is set to 0°F or below. Proper storage at home extends the life and quality of every cut. And if you're unsure about any product, our customer team can walk you through exactly what to expect from each item's texture, flavor, and appearance.

Back to Journal